The blogAnxiety & Overthinking

Does Positive Thinking Help Anxiety? Try One True Thing

Jessica Davis on the Block Out the Noise thumbnail for Why Positive Thinking Can Make Anxiety Worse

Does positive thinking help anxiety when you say the words out loud and your own mind answers “no, it isn’t” before you even finish? Maybe you have a gratitude note on your phone with three good things you wrote months ago and haven’t opened since.

You’ve tried affirmations. You’ve told yourself to be excited, grateful and confident. Instead of feeling better, you felt fake. Then you landed on the conclusion that hurts the most: everybody else can do this, so there must be something wrong with me.

There isn’t. What you’re running into is anxiety, and it has a very specific move here. This post comes from Episode 80 of Block Out the Noise, Why Positive Thinking Can Make Anxiety Worse, and it walks you through why forced positivity backfires, what helps instead and one small question you can start asking today.

Watch or listen to this episode

Why Positive Thinking Can Backfire When You’re Anxious

Most of us were taught to start with the hardest version of positive thinking: forcing yourself to feel something you don’t feel yet. When your mind pushes back, you treat that pushback as proof that you’re failing. That loop can leave you feeling worse after a “good” exercise.

Part of the problem is that positive thinking is one of those phrases that sounds simple but actually means five different things:

  • Gratitude
  • Affirmations
  • Challenging an anxious thought
  • Noticing a good moment
  • Self-compassion

Those are not the same exercise. If you’ve been treating them like they are, that may be why nothing has stuck.

Here’s what that can look like in everyday life. You sit in your car before work and tell yourself “today is going to be amazing.” Your stomach is still in knots. Now you’re anxious about the day and annoyed that the pep talk didn’t work, which is two hard feelings instead of one.

Noticing vs. Forcing: The Difference Your Brain Can Feel

Here’s the distinction that changes everything. Noticing asks you to tell the truth. Forced positivity asks you to feel something on command.

“I got out of bed today.” That is true. “I answered the message I’ve been avoiding.” That’s also true.

Neither statement requires you to feel grateful, confident or okay. They just ask you to let one real thing register.

Compare that with “everything is amazing,” “I love my life” or “I am completely confident.” If you don’t believe those words, your mind will argue back. That’s not because you’re negative. It’s because your mind knows you’re trying to leap over what is real.

You don’t need to leap. You just need to start with something that is true enough and stand on that. Your brain knows the difference between something you noticed and something you’re trying to make yourself believe.

Gratitude isn’t a button

That’s why “just be grateful” can land so badly. You can notice that you made it through a difficult morning, but being grateful is a feeling, and feelings arrive when they arrive. Telling yourself you should feel grateful when you don’t can turn one hard feeling into two.

First you feel anxious, flat or frustrated, whatever was already there. Then you feel guilty for not being grateful enough on top of it.

That isn’t a gratitude practice. That’s self-criticism wearing a wellness label.

Jessica Davis, Block Out the Noise Episode 80

Why Do Affirmations Make Me Feel Worse?

There’s another reason this gets hard. People tell you to start with the biggest possible claim about yourself, like “I am lovable,” “I am confident,” “I’m successful” or “people enjoy being around me.”

For some people, those statements feel encouraging. For anyone struggling with low self-worth, the statement starts an argument instead. You say “I’m lovable,” and your mind says “prove it.” You say “people like me,” and your mind pulls up every awkward conversation from the last 10 years.

There’s research behind this. In a study led by psychologist Joanne Wood and described by the Greater Good Science Center at UC Berkeley, people repeated the statement “I am a lovable person” 16 times. Participants with low self-esteem who repeated it felt worse afterward, while those with high self-esteem felt slightly better.

The researchers’ idea, as that same Greater Good article explains, was that a statement like this can remind people with low self-esteem of the standards they feel they fall short of. In a follow-up study, people with low self-esteem who were allowed to note ways the statement wasn’t true actually ended up in a better mood than people told to focus only on the positive evidence.

That doesn’t mean kind self-talk is bad. It means a thought has to be believable enough for your mind to hold it. If an affirmation keeps starting a fight in your head, that’s not a sign you’re doing it wrong. It’s a sign the statement is too far from where you are right now.

What Is Neutral Thinking?

Here’s where most people get stuck. You think the choice is between a negative thought that feels honest and a positive one that feels fake. There’s a third option: neutral.

Neutral isn’t exciting. It isn’t inspirational, and it wouldn’t look good on a quote graphic. Neutral is usually where change actually begins.

A neutral thought doesn’t argue that everything is fine. It also doesn’t let anxiety have the last word. It says what you actually know, and it leaves room for what you don’t know yet.

The researchers behind that affirmation study pointed in a similar direction. As the Greater Good Science Center reports, they suggested that specific statements, like “I select good gifts for people,” may be less likely than big, global ones to set off the thoughts that argue back. A small, believable thought gives your mind less to fight with.

Think of it as accuracy. The goal was never “I feel amazing.” The goal is that anxiety stops being the only voice giving evidence.

Neutral Thinking Examples for Anxious Moments

Here are the examples from the episode, side by side, so you can see how each kind of thought sounds:

What anxiety saysForced positive thoughtNeutral thought
“I’m going to ruin this.”“I’m going to be great.”“I don’t know how this will go, but I’ve handled hard things before.”
“Nobody wants me there.”“It will be great. I’m going to have a wonderful time.”“I can’t know what people are thinking. I can show up for a while and see.”
“I’m falling apart.”“I’m completely fine.”“This is hard right now, and I am still here.”

Notice what the neutral thoughts do. They don’t deny the fear, and they don’t promise a happy ending. They just add a piece of information anxiety left out.

You can build your own the same way. Before a big work presentation, “I’m going to embarrass myself” can become “I’ve prepared, and I can get through the first slide.” Before a family dinner where things might get tense, “this is going to be a disaster” can become “I don’t know how tonight will go, and I can step outside for a minute if I need to.”

That isn’t fake positivity. That’s accuracy.

Jessica Davis, Block Out the Noise Episode 80

Does Positive Thinking Help Anxiety? Here’s What Helps

I want to be clear about something. There is real clinical work behind helping people notice and stay with good experiences. It isn’t fluff.

A randomized clinical trial published in JAMA Network Open followed 98 adults who had very low positive emotion along with moderate to severe depression or anxiety. They received 15 weekly sessions of either Positive Affect Treatment, which focuses on reward, or a therapy aimed at negative emotion and threat. Positive Affect Treatment led to greater improvement in their overall clinical status, and that advantage was still there at a one-month follow-up.

According to Southern Methodist University’s summary of the trial, the positive therapy included exercises that re-engage people with rewarding activities and redirect attention toward positive experiences, along with practices such as gratitude and savoring.

Let me be careful here. The gap between the two therapies was modest. It wasn’t a landslide.

The useful version isn’t forcing happiness. It’s making room for something to register before anxiety deletes it.

How anxiety deletes the good stuff

Anxiety is quick. You get a compliment, and anxiety says “they were just being nice.” You finish a hard task, and anxiety tells you it wasn’t that hard. You have an okay afternoon, and anxiety loves to say “enjoy it while it lasts.”

The good thing happens, and your mind throws it away before it gets to land. The Greater Good Science Center’s guide to savoring describes savoring as being mindfully engaged and aware of your feelings during positive events. It also notes that studies show the more negative thoughts people have after a personal achievement, the less likely they are to enjoy it.

So this isn’t about convincing yourself life is perfect. It’s about giving reality equal airtime.

Adding vs. Replacing: The Version That Backfires

Picture two people with the same reminder on their phone, both writing down something good. Both write “the coffee was decent” or “my friend texted me back” or “I got outside for 10 minutes.” One of them is getting better. The other is quietly going backward, and from the outside you can’t tell which is which.

The difference is that one of them is adding something. The other is trying to replace something.

What adding sounds like

  • “I feel anxious. I also had a decent cup of coffee.”
  • “Today was difficult, and my dog made me laugh.”
  • “I’m low right now, and I got myself through the morning.”

Nothing has to disappear for any of those to be true.

What replacing sounds like

  • “I noticed something good, so why am I still anxious?”
  • “I wrote down three things I should be grateful for. So why do I still feel awful?”
  • “I did the exercise and it didn’t fix me.”

That’s where the practice turns into pressure. You’re no longer noticing a good thing. You’re asking the good thing to remove the bad one, and when the anxiety stays, the exercise itself becomes more evidence against you.

So here’s the rule: you’re allowed to notice something true without requiring it to change your mood. A good moment can sit beside a hard one. Anxiety can stay in the room while you notice something else.

Research on acceptance points the same way. A set of studies in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology found that people who tend to accept their emotions and thoughts, instead of judging them, had better psychological health. Part of the reason was that they felt less negative emotion when they were stressed.

If you’ve spent years rehearsing the negative version, of course it feels more believable. Repetition makes a familiar thought feel true, but repetition isn’t proof. It’s just practice, and you can practice something else without lying to yourself. If you tend to judge yourself hard for every slip, this post on how to stop beating yourself up over mistakes goes deeper on that habit.

How to Practice “One True Thing” This Week

Here’s what I want you to do this week. Not a five-item gratitude list, not affirmations you don’t believe and not waiting until you feel grateful. One question, once a day, twice if it feels supportive rather than required.

Ask yourself: What’s one true thing about right now? Not one good thing. One true thing.

  1. Ask it once a day. Twice is fine if it feels supportive rather than required. You don’t need a longer list.
  2. Let small answers count. Answers like “I got out of bed,” “I took a shower even though I didn’t want to” or “this is a Saturday and I’m still going” absolutely count.
  3. Write it down or say it out loud. Put it in your notes app, on a sticky note or say one sentence into a voice memo. One sentence is enough.
  4. Don’t score it. You don’t have to find something inspiring. You’re practicing recognition, not performance.
  5. Let the good ones stay a little longer. When you do notice something good, let it stay about five seconds longer than you normally would. If someone says something kind, don’t immediately explain it away. If you finish something difficult, let yourself register that you finished.
  6. Let the anxiety stay if it stays. The question isn’t a test of whether your mood changes. It’s a way of giving your mind more than one piece of information.

That fifth step lines up with what the Greater Good Science Center calls taking a mental photograph, consciously noticing the things you want to remember later. You get a peaceful moment, and instead of interrogating whether it will last, you just let it be.

What it looks like when it’s working

You don’t become somebody who wakes up excited to make the bed. You don’t become positive all the time. You become someone who can have a hard day without the hard day erasing every other true thing in it.

If this ever turns into something you feel you have to do perfectly, set it down. The point is to help you through the overthinking and the anxiety, not to give you one more thing to get right. For more small, doable tools like this one, grab the free Anxiety Survival Toolkit, and if you want to look at the bigger picture of how you relate to anxiety, read how to change your relationship with anxiety, one small step at a time.

You are not bad at being positive. You were taught to force a feeling, then blame yourself when it didn’t arrive.

Jessica Davis, Block Out the Noise Episode 80

Hear the full episode on positive thinking and anxiety

In Episode 80 I walk through all five kinds of positive thinking, the neutral thoughts that actually hold up and the one question I want on your phone this week. Stay neutral, stay honest and give reality a little more room than anxiety has been willing to give it.

Questions people ask

It can, but not the forced kind. Telling yourself to feel grateful or confident on command often makes your mind argue back. What tends to help is noticing what’s actually true, including the good moments, and letting them register without expecting them to erase the anxiety.

Yes, it’s common. Gratitude is a feeling, and feelings arrive when they arrive. When you tell yourself you should feel grateful and you don’t, you can end up with the original hard feeling plus guilt on top. Try noticing one true thing instead of trying to feel thankful on cue.

Positive thinking often asks you to believe something you don’t believe yet, like “I’m going to be great.” Neutral thinking sticks to what you actually know, like “I don’t know how this will go, but I’ve handled hard things before.” It doesn’t deny the fear. It just stops anxiety from being the only voice giving evidence.

No. Neutral thinking isn’t settling and it isn’t pretending. It’s accuracy. It gives your mind more than one piece of information, so a hard moment and a good moment can both be true at the same time.

Slow the moment down on purpose. When someone says something kind or you finish something hard, let it stay about five seconds longer than you normally would before anxiety gets to comment. You’re not arguing with anxiety. You’re just giving the good thing a chance to land.

Once a day is plenty, twice if it feels supportive rather than required. Write it in your notes app, on a sticky note or in a quick voice memo. If it starts to feel like a chore you have to do perfectly, take a break from it.

Quick reminder: Block Out the Noise is here to support and guide you, but it is not a replacement for talking to someone in real life. If you’re struggling with your mental health, please reach out to a therapist. If you’re in crisis, contact emergency services or a local helpline. You don’t have to go through it alone.

Share this post

Free download

Get the Anxiety Survival Toolkit

Courage Calls, a 3-minute emergency reset, a guided meditation and 75 coping strategies. Real tools you can use anytime, anywhere.

Send me the toolkit

Free. Unsubscribe anytime.

Every week in your inbox

Anxiety doesn’t define you.

New episodes, free tools and my notes, in your inbox every week.

[botn_signup button="Subscribe"]

Free. Unsubscribe anytime.

Jessica Davis