The blogAnxiety & Overthinking

How to Change Your Relationship With Anxiety, One Small Step

Jessica Davis on the Block Out the Noise thumbnail for You're Not Afraid of Anxiety. You're Afraid of This.

Learning how to change your relationship with anxiety starts with a friend you never picked. You didn’t meet them. You didn’t decide to keep them. They just started showing up, and at some point you stopped questioning it.

They come to the job interview, the first date, the family dinner and the drive home afterwards. They talk while you’re trying to sleep. They replay a conversation from four years ago and tell you what you should have said. Then, every so often, they tell you they’re doing it for your own good.

If that sounds familiar, you aren’t the only one. This post comes from Episode 81 of Block Out the Noise, where I talk about why this friendship is so hard to end, how it gets built, what starts to loosen it, and the question so many people are afraid to ask out loud.

Watch or listen to this episode

Anxiety Feels Like a Friend You Never Picked

One person wrote this to their anxiety: “You’ve been with me for as long as I can remember, and I’d love to know a life without you.” That’s the friendship I want to talk about. It isn’t one you signed up for, and it isn’t one you want. It’s one you can’t seem to end.

Part of what makes it so sticky is that anxiety doesn’t only scare you. It also makes you a deal.

Anxiety doesn’t just scare you, it makes you a promise.

Jessica Davis, Block Out the Noise Episode 81

The promise sounds like this: if you worry enough, you’ll be prepared. If you avoid the things that scare you, you won’t have to find out whether you can handle them.

For a while, that promise can feel so true. You worry before an interview, so you prepare more. You worry before a trip, so you check every detail.

Researchers have a name for this kind of thinking. A 2017 study in Frontiers in Psychology describes beliefs like “worrying helps me cope” as positive beliefs about worry, and it found that worry and people’s beliefs about their own worry both predicted anxiety symptoms months later. In other words, what you believe about worry matters, not only the worry itself.

Did anxiety really help?

After the interview goes fine, your brain makes a connection: see, anxiety helped. Did it, though?

Maybe you prepared because you’re a responsible person. Maybe the trip went fine because you’re capable of handling a trip. Maybe the conversation was fine because it was fine, not because you rehearsed it three hours beforehand.

When anxiety gets the credit every time you get through something, it stops feeling helpful sometimes and starts feeling necessary all the time. That’s when anxiety stops feeling like a feeling and starts feeling like a relationship. Here’s what that credit grab can look like:

What anxiety takes credit forWhat actually happened
“You only did well in the meeting because you worried all weekend.”You know your work, and you showed up and did it.
“The trip went smoothly because you checked everything five times.”You’re capable of planning a trip.
“That talk with your partner went okay because you practiced every line.”The talk went okay. You care, and that came through.
“Skipping the party kept you safe.”You missed the party, and you never got to see how it would have gone.

Why This Friendship Is So Hard to Leave

History is part of it. This friend was there in the worst year of your life. They were there when nobody else was. They’ve been in the room for what feels like every big thing that has ever happened to you.

That isn’t loyalty, though. It’s proximity, and we mix those two up all the time. Anxiety was there because anxiety comes with you. That doesn’t mean it carried you, and it doesn’t mean it earned a seat at the table.

The biggest piece is this: people stay when they stop believing anything else is available to them. What you believe your options are shapes whether leaving even feels possible. Anxiety does the same thing, just quietly. It slowly fills the space where your other options used to sit.

Why Does Avoidance Make Anxiety Worse?

At first, it’s one party. You skip it because you’re tired or convinced you’ll feel awkward. Then it’s a phone call. Then it’s driving somewhere unfamiliar.

Then it’s a job you actually want. Sadly, it can even become saying what you really think.

It doesn’t ask you for a whole life at once. It asks for one small concession at a time.

Jessica Davis, Block Out the Noise Episode 81

None of those choices seems life changing on its own, and that’s how it gets you. Eventually you aren’t making choices based on what you want anymore. You’re making them based on what anxiety will allow.

That’s the control part. Anxiety doesn’t make every decision for you. It makes every other option feel too dangerous or not possible.

There’s a clear reason this happens. Cleveland Clinic’s guide to exposure therapy explains that when we’re afraid of something, we tend to avoid the objects, activities or situations related to it, and while that can help in the short term, over time it can make our fears worse. Avoidance works fast, and that’s exactly why it’s so hard to stop.

In everyday adult life, those small concessions can look like:

  • At work: keeping your camera off in every meeting, or not applying for the role you’d be great at.
  • In friendships: answering texts days later so you don’t have to make plans.
  • At home: letting the voicemail pile up or putting off the appointment you keep meaning to book.
  • In relationships: swallowing what you really think so nobody gets upset.

If you see yourself in that list, there’s nothing wrong with you. You’ve been listening to a very persuasive friend. I also wrote about this pattern in why anxiety keeps you stuck.

The Mixed Friend: Why Rare Relief Keeps You Hooked

There’s one more piece, and this one matters. A consistently awful friendship is easier to leave than a mixed one. If someone is cold every single day, eventually you get clarity. You can say this isn’t okay.

If someone is warm on Tuesday and rude on Thursday, you never reach a conclusion. You stay in the checking and the analyzing, hoping the good version comes back.

Relief that shows up even rarely is harder to walk away from than relief that never comes at all. Behavior researchers have seen something similar. A research review on resistance to extinction describes the partial reinforcement extinction effect: a response that was rewarded every time usually fades more quickly once the reward stops than one that was rewarded only some of the time.

Your anxiety is the mixed kind. Sometimes it looks responsible. Sometimes it looks caring, or like high standards, or even like intuition.

It tells you to check one more time, and for a few minutes you do feel better. So your brain says, maybe we need this.

That relief only lasts a moment, and it makes the fear more believable the next time around. Something that’s supposed to protect you but keeps you from living your life isn’t protection anymore. It’s a prison with very convincing walls.

Who Am I Without Anxiety?

Here’s the question that holds this whole friendship together. People aren’t always afraid of the anxiety leaving. They’re afraid of what might leave with it.

  • If I’m not worrying all the time, will I stop caring?
  • If I’m not preparing for the worst, will I get caught off guard?
  • If I’m calmer, will I lose my edge?

That makes sense. If worry has filled every quiet moment, quiet can feel strange. If fear has pushed you forward for years, calm can feel like you’re becoming careless. Some people say that when they aren’t worrying about something, they feel lost, like they don’t know what to do with themselves.

Anxiety isn’t personality, though. It shaped choices you made and choices you didn’t make.

Jessica Davis, Block Out the Noise Episode 81

It isn’t your values or your sense of humor. It isn’t your ambition, and it surely isn’t your creativity. It isn’t the way you care about people either.

Those things are still yours. Without anxiety doing so much of the talking, you just have more room in your head to be that person.

Why Does Anxiety Come Out of Nowhere?

So how does a friendship like this get built? It never happens in one moment. Think about a tornado.

A tornado isn’t one thing going wrong. It takes several things at the same time: warm, moist air near the ground, air that keeps rising once it starts, something to shove that air upward, and winds that change speed and direction higher up, which sets the whole column spinning. Take one of those away and you might get a nasty storm, but you won’t get a tornado.

Anxiety can work the same way. Here are some of the ingredients that can stack up:

  • Background worry: the low hum that’s been running all day.
  • Low confidence: not feeling sure of yourself in this particular thing.
  • Something new: you’ve never done it before, so you don’t have much evidence about how it will go.
  • Being tired: running on too little sleep or energy.
  • Something unprocessed: carrying a stress you haven’t had time to deal with.

Any one of those on its own, you can usually handle. Stack enough of them on the same day and things start spinning. Yesterday you felt fine because you only had two of the ingredients. Today you have five.

When you don’t notice them building, anxiety feels like it came out of nowhere.

Being tired is one of those ingredients. UC Berkeley researchers found that sleep deprivation amplifies anticipatory anxiety by firing up the brain’s amygdala and insular cortex, and the effect was most dramatic for people who were naturally anxious to begin with.

Here’s where the comparison breaks, though. Tornadoes are rare. Anxiety isn’t.

The reason is that nothing ever challenges the ingredients you avoid, so nothing gets tested. The same ingredients are still sitting there the next week, ready to go again.

What to Do When the Storm Has Already Formed

Sometimes you’ll hear people say, just push through. I’m not taking away from that.

Sometimes pushing through is exactly what gets you to the other side. You feel nervous, but you go anyway. You make the call, you have the conversation, you walk into the room. Those moments matter, since they give you proof.

It depends where you are, though. Once the tornado has already formed, pushing through isn’t helpful advice. You’re already pushing, and you’re giving it everything you have. Being told to give it more just sounds like one more failure.

You aren’t failing. You’re overwhelmed.

If you’re in that place right now, with tears, a tight chest and a feeling that you can’t breathe, start somewhere else:

  1. Put your feet on the floor. Feel the ground holding you up.
  2. Make your exhale longer than your inhale. Breathe in, then let the breath out slowly, a little longer than it took to breathe in.
  3. Look around and name five things you can see. Say them in your head or out loud.
  4. Touch something solid. The chair, the desk, the counter or your clothing.

These steps line up with a well known grounding exercise. The University of Rochester Medical Center’s 5-4-3-2-1 coping technique suggests starting with slow, deep, long breaths to help you return to a calmer state, then noticing five things you see, four you can touch, three you hear, two you can smell and one you can taste.

You aren’t solving your whole life in that moment. You’re grounding yourself so you can decide what comes next. For more quick resets, the free Anxiety Survival Toolkit includes a 3-minute emergency reset.

How to Change Your Relationship With Anxiety in Five Small Steps

Everything here is for before you get to the tornado. That window is the one most people skip. Most people think the only choices are to avoid the thing or force themselves through the biggest version of it. You can make the situation smaller first.

Take speaking in front of people. The first step isn’t walking on stage and doing it cold. You say it out loud to yourself and fix what sounds wrong. Then you say it to one person, then a couple more, then a room.

That’s facing the fear with a plan. Your brain now has information it didn’t have before: you can feel anxious and still do something about it.

Therapists use this same idea. Cleveland Clinic describes graded exposure as listing feared activities and situations in order of intensity, starting with mild to moderately difficult ones and working up to harder ones over time.

Your step-by-step plan for this week

  1. Pick one thing anxiety has been talking you out of. Not the biggest thing or the hardest thing. Choose something that matters to you but is small enough to begin.
  2. Write down five steps between where you are now and the full thing.
  3. Make the first step tiny. So small that part of you thinks, really? That’s it? Yes, that’s it.
  4. Do the first step this week. Don’t wait to feel ready.
  5. Notice what happened. Every step you take gives you more evidence.

Let’s say anxiety has kept you from going to the gym. Your five steps might look like this:

  1. Put your gym clothes on.
  2. Drive to the parking lot.
  3. Walk inside for five minutes and just look at what they have.
  4. Do one short workout.
  5. Stay for the amount of time you originally planned.

You’re not doing this to impress anybody. You’re doing it so your brain has something real to work with. Building evidence like this is the heart of the C.O.U.R.A.G.E. Method, and if you like a longer plan, the free 90-Day Courage Challenge cheat sheet helps you set realistic goals and stay consistent.

Don’t wait until you feel ready, since ready isn’t coming the way anxiety keeps promising it will. You aren’t trying to be calm while you do it. You’re trying to do it while you aren’t calm. If waiting to feel ready is a pattern for you, I go deeper on it in how to stop overthinking and procrastination.

What Happens to the Friend Over Time

So what happens to your friend while you’re doing all this? They don’t leave overnight. I don’t believe anxiety has to disappear completely for you to have a good life anyway. You’ll still have hard days.

Everyone has those. What changes is the relationship, once you change how you respond.

Think about what actually ends a tornado. Nothing beats it. It gets cut off from the warm air feeding it, and it weakens. That’s what you’re going to do:

  • Stop feeding it the story that discomfort means danger.
  • Stop letting it take credit for things you were capable of handling.
  • Collect evidence every time you take a step, even a small one.

The first time you try this, anxiety may scream at you. By the fifth time, it sounds more like, I’m nervous about this, but all right. At some point you’ll notice you can see what it was doing. It was trying to protect you, badly, with the only method it had.

You didn’t choose this friend. You’ve carried them a long time, and some part of you is scared of who you’d be without them. This friendship changes when you change. Not because you fought harder, but because you stopped being someone who needs protecting from everything.

Listen to the Full Episode

In the full episode, I walk through the toxic friend, the tornado and the five small steps in my own words, plus a few more things people have shared about living with anxiety. Trust yourself, and never forget you have what it takes to block out the noise.

Questions people ask

Start by noticing when anxiety takes credit for things you did yourself. Then pick one thing it has talked you out of, break it into five small steps and do the first one this week. Each step gives your brain evidence that you can feel anxious and still act. Over time, anxiety gets less say, and you get more room.

No. You’re still you. Anxiety shaped some choices you made and didn’t make, but it isn’t your values, your humor, your ambition, your creativity or the way you care about people. Those things are yours. With less fear doing the talking, you have more room to be that person.

Anxiety is trying to keep you safe from discomfort, embarrassment or the unknown. It promises that if you worry enough or avoid enough, nothing bad will happen. The problem is that it protects you badly, by shrinking your choices until you’re living by what anxiety will allow.

Avoidance works fast, and that’s exactly why it’s so hard to stop. Each small concession seems harmless, but together they shrink your life, and the fear never gets tested. Small, planned steps toward the thing you avoid give your brain new information instead.

Often it comes down to what is stacking up. Several ingredients can stack up on the same day, like background worry, low confidence, something new, being tired and stress you haven’t dealt with. One on its own is usually manageable, but enough of them together can make anxiety feel sudden.

Yes, that makes sense. If worry has filled every quiet moment for years, quiet can feel strange, and calm can feel like you’re being careless. That feeling usually eases as you collect evidence that you can still care, prepare and do well without anxiety running the show.

Quick reminder: Block Out the Noise is here to support and guide you, but it is not a replacement for talking to someone in real life. If you’re struggling with your mental health, please reach out to a therapist. If you’re in crisis, contact emergency services or a local helpline. You don’t have to go through it alone.

Share this post

Free download

Get the Anxiety Survival Toolkit

Courage Calls, a 3-minute emergency reset, a guided meditation and 75 coping strategies. Real tools you can use anytime, anywhere.

Send me the toolkit

Free. Unsubscribe anytime.

Every week in your inbox

Anxiety doesn’t define you.

New episodes, free tools and my notes, in your inbox every week.

[botn_signup button="Subscribe"]

Free. Unsubscribe anytime.

Jessica Davis