The blogAnxiety & Overthinking

How to Stop Beating Yourself Up Over Mistakes (3 Questions)

Jessica Davis on the Block Out the Noise thumbnail for What Your Mistakes Are Trying to Teach You

You made a decision, it didn’t turn out the way you hoped, and now you’re lying awake wondering how to stop beating yourself up over mistakes you can’t take back. You replay the conversation. You replay the moment you said yes, or the moment you didn’t speak up. Suddenly you’re questioning everything: your judgment, your abilities, even whether you should trust yourself to make another decision.

If that sounds familiar, you’re in good company. We’ve all made decisions we wish we could change. Some of them hurt someone else, and some of them hurt us in ways we never saw coming. The good news is that you don’t have to keep carrying that weight forever.

This post comes from Episode 88 of Block Out the Noise, What Your Mistakes Are Trying to Teach You. I’ll walk you through why your mind keeps replaying the past, the difference between beating yourself up and owning a mistake, and three questions you can ask yourself today to learn from it and move forward.

Watch or listen to this episode

You are not your mistakes

It’s always easy to look back and judge. When you know how the story ended, every warning sign looks obvious. In the moment, though, you were working with what you had: the information, the feelings and the fear you were carrying right then.

Here’s what I believe with my whole heart. You are not the decision that didn’t work out, the business that failed or the situation that didn’t go the way you planned. What matters is what you do next.

I think we end up being measured by how we respond to those situations.

Jessica Davis, Block Out the Noise Episode 88

How do you bounce back? How do you keep pushing forward after something goes wrong? That’s where your strength is.

A mistake is something that happened. It isn’t who you are.

This matters for anyone who lives with anxiety, because anxiety loves to turn one moment into a life sentence. You sent the email too fast, so you must be careless. You picked the wrong apartment, so you can’t be trusted with big choices. Those are stories anxiety tells, and they skip right past the part where you get to learn and do it differently next time.

Two kinds of decisions that don’t work out

When I think about the decisions people regret, I see two different categories. Most of us have a mix of both, especially as we get older.

  • You tried your best and it still didn’t work. You weighed the options, made the call that made sense, and the outcome was still disappointing. Maybe the new job wasn’t what they promised, or the move didn’t bring the fresh start you hoped for.
  • You overlooked what you already knew. Something in you was saying no, and you went that direction anyway. Maybe you stayed in a relationship you knew wasn’t a healthy match, or said yes to a commitment you already knew you didn’t have room for.

Either way, the goal is the same. You’re not trying to decide how much punishment you deserve. You’re trying to figure out what this situation can teach you.

What beating yourself up sounds likeWhat learning from it sounds like
“I’m so stupid. How could I do that?”“What was going on for me when I made that choice?”
“I always ruin everything.”“What would I do differently if this came up again?”
“I can’t trust myself anymore.”“What do I want to take from this so it doesn’t repeat?”
“It’s all their fault.”“What part of this was mine to own?”

Why your mind keeps replaying the mistake

If you’ve ever replayed a conversation for the hundredth time, wishing you’d said something different, there’s a name for that loop. Cleveland Clinic describes rumination as your mind replaying the same negative thoughts without finding a solution, and it lists mistakes and regrets among the most common topics. The same article notes that, over time, rumination can make anxiety, depression, self-doubt, shame and stress worse.

Here’s something that might surprise you. Thinking about what you could have done differently isn’t a bad thing on its own. A paper on the functional theory of counterfactual thinking explains that thinking about “what might have been” can help people improve, because those thoughts can directly fuel plans for what to do next time.

That same paper also points out where it goes wrong. Some of these thoughts turn into fuel for rumination and self-blame, and they bring no benefit for changing what you do. So the question isn’t whether you think about the mistake. It’s whether you’re thinking about it in a way that leads somewhere.

That’s the difference between replaying and reflecting. Replaying keeps asking, “Why did I do that?” with no answer that ever feels good enough. Reflecting asks questions that point forward, which is exactly what the three questions later in this post are built to do.

Blame, shame or ownership

When a decision goes badly, there are two easy places to land. One is shame, where you keep punishing yourself. The other is blame, where you put it all on someone else. A lot of people make a decision and then look for someone to blame without taking any accountability.

I want something different for you. Ownership sounds like, “I knew this probably wasn’t going to work, and I ignored that voice.” It isn’t about beating yourself up. It’s about being honest so you can actually learn.

Research backs this up. A paper in the European Journal of Social Psychology, titled No genuine self-forgiveness without accepting responsibility, describes “pseudo self-forgiveness” as feeling better by downplaying your responsibility. In its studies, people who reaffirmed the values they had gone against, for example by admitting the wrongdoing to the person affected, could accept responsibility with much less of a hit to how they saw themselves.

Being kind to yourself doesn’t mean letting yourself off the hook, either. In a set of four experiments on self-compassion after failure, people who took a self-compassionate approach were more motivated to make amends for a recent wrong and to avoid repeating it. After failing a test, they also spent more time studying for a difficult test.

So you don’t have to choose between being gentle with yourself and taking responsibility. The two work together. Owning it is what lets you learn, and kindness is what keeps you from getting stuck in shame while you do.

Why anxiety makes it hard to trust yourself

One of the hardest parts of anxiety is that it makes it so hard to hear your own voice. There’s so much noise: the negativity, the fear, the endless what-ifs. Underneath all of that is a quieter voice that knows what’s right for you.

Sometimes that voice is saying, “This is the direction we need to go, even if it’s scary.” Other times it’s saying, “This doesn’t line up with who we are, and we don’t have to please this other person.” After a mistake, anxiety tells you that voice can’t be trusted. Often the truth is that you heard it and didn’t listen.

Here’s what that can look like in everyday life. A job offer sounded too good to be true, and you took it anyway. A friend asked for more than you could give, and you said yes to keep the peace. Something felt off in a relationship, and you talked yourself out of it.

That’s actually hopeful. It means the wisdom was there all along. Learning from a mistake is part of how you start hearing that voice again and trusting it a little more each time.

One small way to start: when you work through the first question below, write down what your gut was telling you at the time you made the decision. Over time, that can help you notice the voice the next time it speaks up, even when the noise is loud. If second-guessing yourself is a big part of your anxiety, you might also like this post on how to feel confident when you’re second-guessing yourself.

How to stop beating yourself up over mistakes: 3 questions

If you want to know how to learn from your mistakes and move on, these three questions are where I’d start. The next time you catch yourself putting yourself down for a decision you made, stop and ask them. Grab a notebook or the notes app on your phone and actually write the answers down. Writing gives the thoughts somewhere to go, and Cleveland Clinic suggests writing down thoughts that keep coming back and then physically putting the paper away.

1. What was my reasoning for the decision I made?

Be honest about why you made the choice you made. This isn’t about punishing yourself one way or another. It’s about understanding what was really going on.

Decisions get made for all kinds of reasons:

  • You wanted to take a chance. You saw an opportunity and went for it.
  • You were afraid. Fear made the choice for you, maybe to avoid conflict or to avoid being alone.
  • You were trying to trust yourself. You followed your gut, and it didn’t work out this time.
  • You wanted to not feel. Sometimes we act on impulse to escape an uncomfortable feeling.

If you made a decision that wasn’t from your best intentions, or you hurt someone because of it, own that. Taking accountability is what lets you learn from it and grow into the person you want to be.

2. What would I have done differently?

This question helps you find the exact spot where you could have made a different choice. Get specific. “I should have been better” doesn’t give you much to work with. “I could have given myself a day to think before I said yes” does.

Look for small, concrete changes like these:

  • Slowing down instead of rushing to make a choice.
  • Asking one more question before agreeing to something.
  • Paying attention to the warning signs you noticed and pushed aside.
  • Being honest with someone sooner instead of waiting until it blew up.

Once you know what you’d change, you have something you can actually use going forward. This is the forward-looking kind of thinking the counterfactual thinking research describes, where looking back helps shape what you do next.

3. What do I want to learn from this?

This is the question that turns a painful moment into something useful. What do you want to take with you? What were the pros and cons? How do you make sure this doesn’t turn into a vicious cycle where you keep repeating the same mistake?

Here’s a simple way to work through all three questions:

  1. Name the decision in one sentence, without insults. “I took the job without asking about the hours” instead of “I’m an idiot.”
  2. Write your reasoning. Was it a chance, fear, trusting yourself or trying not to feel?
  3. Write one thing you’d do differently, as specific as you can make it.
  4. Write the lesson as something you’ll do next time: “Next time, I’ll ask about the hours before I say yes.”
  5. Own your part, and if someone else was affected, decide whether there’s something you want to make right.
  6. Close the notebook. You’ve done the work. When the replay starts again, remind yourself that you already pulled the lesson out.

If you want more tools for the moments when the replay gets loud, the free Anxiety Survival Toolkit has a 3-minute emergency reset and 75 coping strategies you can try.

Why do I keep making the same mistakes?

If you’ve ever asked yourself this, here’s something I’m a firm believer in.

I’m a firm believer that if we do not learn from the situation, it will repeat itself over and over and over again until we do.

Jessica Davis, Block Out the Noise Episode 88

Think about the person who keeps dating the wrong person, the toxic person, over and over. It’s easy to blame each person they dated. The pattern keeps going, though, until they take the time to learn from it, grow from it and do something different.

The same thing shows up in all kinds of everyday ways. You keep saying yes at work and then feel buried. You keep lending money to the same friend and then feel resentful. You keep waiting until the last minute and then feel panicked.

Each time, the situation looks a little different, but the lesson underneath is the same one you haven’t pulled out yet.

Breaking the pattern means doing the work of figuring out why you’re not making the progress you want. That’s what the three questions are for. They help you stop asking “Why does this always happen to me?” and start asking “What is this trying to teach me?”

How to let go of regret and move forward

Regret can make you stuck. It can make you afraid to try again, and it can change the person you become if you let it sit there long enough. When you take accountability for a decision that didn’t go the way you wanted and you learn from it, you give yourself the chance to heal and move forward with your life.

I want to be clear about one thing. You’re not a better person because of what happened. The mistake didn’t make you better. What you do afterward is what makes the difference.

It’s the choices you decide to make, it’s the person you decide to become

Jessica Davis, Block Out the Noise Episode 88

That’s good news, because it means growth is in your hands. You don’t have to wait for the regret to fade on its own. You get to decide what you do with it.

If the replaying is taking over your days, you don’t have to sort it out alone. Cleveland Clinic notes that therapy can be very effective for rumination, especially when it’s getting in the way of daily life. Talking it through with a therapist can give you support while you sort through it. If you feel stuck in more than one area of life, why anxiety keeps you stuck is a good next read.

Hear the whole episode on what your mistakes are trying to teach you

In the full episode, I share the real moments behind these three questions and why I’m so passionate about learning from every situation. Give it a listen, and bring these questions with you the next time the replay starts.

Questions people ask

Learning how to stop beating yourself up over mistakes starts with noticing when you’re punishing yourself instead of learning. Then ask three questions: What was my reasoning? What would I have done differently? What do I want to learn from this? Writing the answers down turns the replay into a lesson you can actually use, which makes it easier to let it go.

Anxiety often turns one moment into proof that you can’t be trusted, so your mind keeps replaying it looking for a better ending. That replay rarely leads anywhere new. Shifting from “Why did I do that?” to “What would I do differently?” gives your mind somewhere useful to go.

Be honest about why you made the choice, find the specific thing you would change, and decide what lesson you want to carry forward. Own your part without blaming yourself or someone else. Once you’ve pulled out the lesson, you can remind yourself that the work is done when the replay starts again.

Remember that it’s always easier to judge a decision looking back than it was to make it in the moment. Take accountability for your part, learn what you can and then choose what you’ll do next. Regret starts to loosen its grip when it turns into a lesson instead of a punishment.

Yes, as long as forgiving yourself doesn’t mean pretending it didn’t matter. Own what happened, take accountability and decide whether there is something you want to make right. Learning from it is how you become the person you want to be.

No. Often a mistake happens when you heard your inner voice and didn’t listen to it, which means the wisdom was there all along. Each time you learn from a mistake, you get a little better at hearing that voice and trusting it.

Quick reminder: Block Out the Noise is here to support and guide you, but it is not a replacement for talking to someone in real life. If you’re struggling with your mental health, please reach out to a therapist. If you’re in crisis, contact emergency services or a local helpline. You don’t have to go through it alone.

Share this post

Free download

Get the Anxiety Survival Toolkit

Courage Calls, a 3-minute emergency reset, a guided meditation and 75 coping strategies. Real tools you can use anytime, anywhere.

Send me the toolkit

Free. Unsubscribe anytime.

Every week in your inbox

Anxiety doesn’t define you.

New episodes, free tools and my notes, in your inbox every week.

[botn_signup button="Subscribe"]

Free. Unsubscribe anytime.

Jessica Davis