The blogAnxiety & Overthinking

How to Stop Overthinking and Procrastination (It’s Fear)

Jessica Davis on the Block Out the Noise thumbnail for Overthinking Isn't Preparation. It's Hiding.

You’ve researched it, mapped it out, compared every option and listed everything that could go wrong, and you’re still wondering how to stop overthinking and procrastination when you’ve already done the work. The project is sitting there. The application is half filled in. The conversation you keep meaning to have is still in your head.

Here’s the hard part to hear if you’re driven and anxious. Thinking it all the way through is the thing you’re good at, so it doesn’t feel like avoiding anything. It feels responsible.

Most of the time, though, all that extra thinking isn’t giving you clarity. It’s giving fear more time to talk.

This post comes from Episode 82 of Block Out the Noise, “Overthinking Isn’t Preparation. It’s Hiding.”

Watch or listen to this episode

Overthinking Is Fear With a To-Do List

Overthinking is just a fear with a to-do list.

Jessica Davis, Block Out the Noise Episode 82

You don’t procrastinate by doing nothing. You research. You make a plan, then a better plan.

You run every version of it in your head until you feel like you’ve finally earned the right to move. It looks like hard work.

Here’s what it can look like in everyday adult life:

  • At work: you reread the email or the report so many times that it goes out days late, or never goes out at all.
  • With a big change: you research the new job, the move or the business idea for months, but you never apply, call or sign up.
  • In relationships: you rehearse the hard conversation in the shower, in the car and at 2am, and then the moment passes again.

If any of that sounds familiar, you’re not lazy and you’re not broken. You’re doing something very human. You’re trying to feel safe before you do something that feels uncertain.

Why Do Perfectionists Procrastinate?

A lot of overthinking comes from believing there’s one perfect answer out there and you just haven’t found it yet. You keep fixing and tweaking and improving, sure that eventually it’ll be the quality you want. The truth is that there is no perfection. There’s always another option, and when every option stays open, none of them ever feel safe enough to choose.

In an article from Cleveland Clinic on analysis paralysis, a psychotherapist explains that you can become so wrapped up in the different options that no decision gets made, and that wrestling with the idea that there must be one “right” solution can lead to inaction. The same article names fear of failure as another reason people get stuck.

Research points the same way. A 2022 study of perfectionism and procrastination in the International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health notes that past research has consistently found negative perfectionism to be an important driver of procrastination. In that study, fear of failure, along with feeling mentally drained, helped explain the link between perfectionism and putting things off.

Here’s the part that gets me. What if the first plan was the best one? After so many rounds of changes, you might not even remember what that first version looked like. Sometimes you tweak and tweak and tweak, and suddenly it’s worse than where you started.

So at some point you have to get to good enough. There will always be another project, another assignment, another thing right after this one. Stick with what you have, put it out, and see where it lands.

If the feedback makes sense and there are changes worth making, make them then. If it never goes out, you never find out what actually needed changing.

Stop Waiting Until You Feel Ready

Let me ask you the question I’d ask if you were sitting right in front of me. What do you think will make you ready? What sign, what piece of information, what is it that you’re still waiting for?

I’d gently challenge you on that, because I don’t think anything’s missing. You’ve done the preparing. Most of the time, the thing standing between you and starting isn’t information.

It’s fear of the unknown. You don’t know what happens once you start, how it’ll turn out or what it’ll look like, and that uncertainty can feel so big that it sends a signal saying you’re not ready.

Overthinking will tell you that you’re not good enough, not strong enough, not capable enough. It’ll convince you that you’re going to make a fool of yourself and fall flat on your face, and that people will make fun of you. That isn’t preparation. That’s negative self-talk.

Waiting to feel ready is often waiting for the uncertainty to go away, and it rarely does before you start. Research on worry and uncertainty describes how, for people who find uncertainty stressful and upsetting, worry may work as a way to avoid the distress that comes with not knowing.

One way to test this is to name exactly what you think you’re waiting for, then sort it:

  1. Finish the sentence. Write down, “I’ll start when…” and fill it in as honestly as you can.
  2. Ask if it’s information or a feeling. “When I know the deadline for the application” is information. “When I feel more confident” is a feeling.
  3. If it’s information, go get it today. Make the call, read the page or ask the question. Then that reason to wait is gone.
  4. If it’s a feeling, choose the moment anyway. Pick a date and time, and let that choice be what makes you ready.

Here’s what that can look like in real life. You decide you’ll ask for the raise at your review on the 15th, even if your stomach flips. You send the message to the friend you’ve drifted from on Sunday afternoon, even though you haven’t found the perfect words. The feeling may show up after you act, not before.

Ready isn’t a feeling, it’s a decision.

Jessica Davis, Block Out the Noise Episode 82

Ready is a point in time where you just say, I’m going to do it. When that happens, then comes the freedom and the relief. Sometimes the excitement and the fear show up too.

If you wait until you feel ready, you could be waiting a lifetime, and the time you spend waiting is time you’re stalled. Growth doesn’t happen until you push yourself a little outside your comfort zone and reach for something you haven’t reached for before.

Does Anxiety Cause Procrastination?

In an American Psychological Association podcast on why we procrastinate, procrastination researcher Fuschia Sirois explains that we’re not avoiding the task itself. What we’re avoiding is the negative emotions tied to that task. The tasks we put off tend to be unpleasant, and that can range from simply boring to nerve wracking and anxiety provoking.

She describes procrastination as a kind of short-term mood repair. Putting it off gives you immediate relief. In the same conversation, she says procrastination is associated with higher rates of depression, anxiety and stress, which is part of why it’s worth taking seriously.

Overthinking works in a similar way. A paper on worry and avoidance in a cognitive behavioral therapy journal describes worry as serving an avoidant function. People who worry often believe it helps them prepare for or problem solve future bad events.

The catch is that avoiding keeps anxiety going. As clinical psychologist Julie Radico writes in an article on how avoidance maintains anxiety, avoidance may help you feel safer in the short term but can keep you feeling anxious over time. It also keeps you from learning that the things you fear aren’t always as scary as they seem.

Put those together and you get a loop that a lot of high achievers know well:

  1. Something matters to you, so it feels uncertain and a little scary.
  2. Planning, researching and rechecking bring some relief, so it feels productive.
  3. The relief fades, the fear is still there, and the task still isn’t done.
  4. You go back to planning, because it worked for a minute last time.

Knowing this can take some of the shame out of it. You’re not failing at discipline. You’re reaching for relief, and there are kinder ways to get it that also move you forward.

Thorough or Avoiding? How to Tell the Difference

Some of you are going to tell me you’re not avoiding anything. You’re just being thorough. That’s fair.

If we’re going to use that word, though, we need some kind of rubric for what thorough actually means. Otherwise it’s just a word we use to feel better about the time we’re spending.

Here’s how you know you’ve crossed over:

  • You’re checking things you already checked. Nothing new is being found. You’re just looking again.
  • You’re changing preferences, not fixing problems. A different font or a reworded sentence isn’t the same as correcting a real mistake.
  • You keep asking whether it could be better, but you haven’t asked anybody else. All the feedback is coming from inside your own head.
  • You can’t name the one specific thing you’re still missing. If you can’t say what you’re waiting for, there’s a good chance it isn’t information.

If more than one of those is true, that isn’t thorough. It’s anxiety wearing a word that makes you feel better about the time.

Here’s a simple way to compare the two:

Being thoroughOverthinking and avoiding
You check what’s required and then stop.You check the same things again and again.
You fix real problems.You change things you simply feel unsure about.
You show it to someone and use their feedback.You only ask yourself if it could be better.
You can name what’s left to do.You can’t say what you’re still waiting for.
You review it when you’re rested.You open it again when you’re tired and stressed.

That last row matters. When you’re tired, stressed and overwhelmed, or you haven’t eaten or slept well, that’s probably the worst possible time to look at it again. The Cleveland Clinic article on analysis paralysis also suggests taking a break and coming back to a decision later.

How to Stop Overthinking and Procrastination

The simplest way I know to break this loop is to decide ahead of time what “thorough enough” means for you. Then, when the urge to reopen it hits, you have something solid to check against instead of a feeling. Here’s how to do it step by step:

  1. Do the required check once. Make sure everything that truly needs to be there is there. This part is fine and good. Go and double check it, definitely.
  2. Pick your “enough” rule up front. Maybe it’s three things you check before you post it. Maybe it’s one person you show it to before you hit send. Maybe it’s a date and time you’re applying by, whether you feel good about it that morning or not.
  3. When the urge to reopen it comes, ask a different question. Don’t ask whether it could be better, because it could always be better. Ask whether you did your three things.
  4. Pass it to someone else. If you’ve already looked at it 20 million times, the best thing you can do is have somebody else look at it. Real feedback teaches you more than another lap through your own head.
  5. Talk back to the doubt. When the voice says it isn’t good enough yet, notice that’s often anxiety, not information. That’s the voice you tell to back off.
  6. Be kind to yourself about the delay. Beating yourself up won’t speed things up.

That last step isn’t just a nice idea. In the APA podcast on procrastination, Sirois explains that forgiveness and self-compassion are simple ways research has found to take the edge off those negative emotions. She also notes that getting more critical of yourself for procrastinating can actually increase the chances that you’ll keep doing it.

When Planning Becomes the Place You Hide

Here’s a harder question, and I’m asking it so you can be honest with yourself. Has planning become the place you go when everything else feels uncertain?

If you’ve spent all this time and energy and you still haven’t moved forward, and you’re not going out, not seeing friends, not seeing family, and there’s no balance anywhere, it’s worth asking what’s really going on. What is it you think you’re missing that means you should spend another weekend away from everybody?

Some careers make this very easy to hide inside. Teachers, business owners, entrepreneurs and therapists all have work where, once you’re done, you’re not really done.

How would you know if you were avoiding? Here are some everyday signs that planning has become an escape:

  • Your weekends disappear. You keep choosing another weekend on the project over time with friends or family.
  • You’ve stopped going out. Plans with people start to feel like they’re in the way of the work.
  • Months go by and nothing is out. The plan keeps growing, but no one has seen it yet.

Planning can become an escape. It feels nice and fun and exciting, and then one day you notice you’re only there because you’re afraid. When that’s where you are, you have two kind options.

Option one: set a deadline

Pick the day it goes out and put it on your calendar. Tell one person the date so it feels real. Between now and then, work from your “enough” rule instead of starting over every time doubt shows up.

Option two: give yourself a break

Step away on purpose. Choose a few evenings or a whole weekend where you don’t touch it, and spend that time with the people you care about. When you come back rested, that’s the moment to be thorough.

The most important thing we have is time. The more you build something, the less time you have for the things you love, so find the balance now, while you’re still working and creating. If you’ve been feeling like this has kept you from moving at all, you might also find why anxiety keeps you stuck helpful.

How to Stop Overthinking and Start Doing

Let’s say you finally do it, and it goes badly. That doesn’t prove you were right to wait. It proves you did something hard, and now you have information you didn’t have before.

Would more time have made the result different? Probably not, because you still wouldn’t have had what you know today. That information only comes from trying.

Waiting usually just means you waited and then found out anyway. Who wants to keep waiting, only to find out two or three years from now that this isn’t something you even want to pursue?

Preparing in private feels safer than trying in public, but preparing in private can’t teach you what trying in public would.

Jessica Davis, Block Out the Noise Episode 82

You see this with applications, with videos, with the conversation you keep meaning to have. Waiting just drags out what’s coming anyway. Here are a few small ways to start doing instead of planning:

  • Pick a date. Choose the day you’re going to send, post, apply or ask, and put it on your calendar.
  • Make the first step tiny. Open the application and fill in your name. Send the first text. Small brave steps still count.
  • Expect fear to come along. You don’t have to wait for anxiety to go quiet before you act. It doesn’t get to define you, and it doesn’t get to decide your timing.

Can you fail? Can you mess up? Can you fall flat on your face? Yes, those are all possibilities.

Isn’t that better than doing nothing? In the planning stage, you’re living out a dream that’s only on paper. Once you actually do it, you start to feel alive in a way only doing can bring. If you want help building that momentum over time, the free 90-Day Courage Challenge cheat sheet walks you through setting realistic goals and staying consistent.

Listen to the full episode

In the full episode, I talk through all of this in my own words, including why ready is a decision and not a feeling.

Questions people ask about overthinking and procrastination

It often is. Overthinking can look like research, planning and comparing options, but when it keeps you from starting, it’s working like procrastination. A good test is whether you can name the one specific thing you’re still missing. If you can’t, the extra thinking is probably about fear, not information.

Waiting to feel ready usually means waiting for the fear of the unknown to go away first. That feeling may never fully come. Ready isn’t a feeling, it’s a decision, a moment where you choose to start even though you don’t know how it’ll turn out.

Start by deciding up front what “thorough enough” means for you. That could be three things you check, one person you show it to, or a date you’ll send it by. When the urge to reopen it comes, ask whether you did those things, not whether it could be better.

Yes, and it’s very common. When you’re tired, stressed or overwhelmed, you lose your fresh eyes, and the changes stop being improvements. Step away, rest, and look again later, or hand it to someone else for feedback.

That doesn’t mean you should have waited. It means you did something hard and now have information you couldn’t have gotten any other way. More time spent planning usually wouldn’t have changed the result, because you wouldn’t have had the feedback that only trying gives you.

Quick reminder: Block Out the Noise is here to support and guide you, but it is not a replacement for talking to someone in real life. If you’re struggling with your mental health, please reach out to a therapist. If you’re in crisis, contact emergency services or a local helpline. You don’t have to go through it alone.

Share this post

Free download

Get the Anxiety Survival Toolkit

Courage Calls, a 3-minute emergency reset, a guided meditation and 75 coping strategies. Real tools you can use anytime, anywhere.

Send me the toolkit

Free. Unsubscribe anytime.

Every week in your inbox

Anxiety doesn’t define you.

New episodes, free tools and my notes, in your inbox every week.

[botn_signup button="Subscribe"]

Free. Unsubscribe anytime.

Jessica Davis